BookPath
Back to Under the Mistletoe Collection Main Page
Comparison Analysis

What is the best order to read Under the Mistletoe Collection?

The Under the Mistletoe Collection universe is complex. Fans are often split between following release dates or the in-universe timeline. We've analyzed the narrative impact of both to help you decide.

Publication Order

Recommended
  • Preserves Twists: Plot reveals are experienced exactly as intended by Ali Hazelwood.
  • Organic Growth: See the world-building and character voices evolve naturally.
Best for 1st-time readers who want the intended suspense and discovery phase.

Chronological

  • Spoiler Warning: Prequels often assume you know key "future" reveals.
  • Historical Flow: Tracks the actual timeline of the universe's events.
Best for completionists and re-readers who want to see history unfold in order.
The Decision Engine Verdict

Stick to Publication Order for your first journey.

Starting with "Cruel Winter with You" is the only way to experience the mysteries and character introductions without being spoiled by prequel details or retroactive world-building.

Start First Book Now

Prefer Listening?

Get the professional narration of "Cruel Winter with You" free with an Audible trial.

Try Audible →

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I read Under the Mistletoe Collection chronologically?

Generally, no. We recommend publication order for first-time readers because prequels often spoil character arcs and plot mysteries established in the original release sequence.

Is Cruel Winter with You a good place to start?

Yes, "Cruel Winter with You" is the definitive starting point for the Under the Mistletoe Collection series as it was designed to introduce the world and its core themes.